California Coastal Commission

LAND FORM ALTERATION POLICY GUIDANCE

VI. SUBDIVISION EXAMPLES

Parcel on Sand Dunes

Key Features to Consider in Lot Layout Plans


Alternative 1 - Conventional Lot Layout.


SITE PLAN CRITERIA

COMMENTS

  • Site Plan Grading and Drainage
  • No consideration of natural topography or landform.
  • Homes have ocean views, with little protection from wind or ocean waves.
  • Significant dune disturbance, may lead to dune destabilization.
  • May require future shoreline armoring if minimal dune protection is removed.
  • Access, Circulation and Utilities
  • Long access road to City/County standards; 4 long, separate driveways required.
  • Long extensions of electric, telephone, water and sewer lines to serve residences.
  • Septic systems would require setback from ocean and water lines.
  • 1 point of connection with main road.
  • Lot Layout, Buildable Area, Sensitive Resources
  • Buildings can be sited on high part of dune for flood protection; should use pier or caisson foundations in the event that dune features migrate.
  • Buildable lot areas the same for each lot: All lots approximately 20% level.
  • No provision of buffer from lateral beach access.
  • No preservation of dune vegetation.

Alternative 2 - Modified Lot Layout.


SITE PLAN CRITERIA

COMMENTS

  • Grading and Drainage
  • Development set behind dune line; reduces grading and impact to dunes from construction.
  • Ocean view possible if buildings are elevated above flood elevation.
  • Future shoreline armoring can be avoided.
  • Natural drainage patterns largely preserved.
  • Access, Circulation, and Utilities
  1. Four private walkways over dunes could impact dune vegetation and destabilize the dune system.
  2. Long access road to County/City requirements; shorter driveways require less grading.
  3. Long extensions of electric, telephone, water and sewer lines to serve residences.
  4. Flexibility in siting septic system due to greater setback from ocean.
  5. 1 point of connection with main road.
  • Lot Layout, Buildable Area, Sensitive Resources
  • Buildings can use pier foundations to get ocean view; at grade elevation can be used for garage or storage, if designed for flood conditions.
  • Buildable lot areas the same for each lot: All lots approximately 20% level.
  • Dunes provide a buffer from lateral beach access.
  • Some preservation of dune vegetation.

Alternative 3 - Lot Layout with Lot Line Changes.


SITE PLAN CRITERIA

COMMENTS

  • Grading and Drainage
  • Development concentrated in areas where dune alteration can be minimized.
  • Minimal grading required for access roads & building pads for all Lots.
  • Future shoreline armoring can be avoided.
  • Natural drainage patterns preserved.
  • Access, Circulation, and Utilities
  • 1 short access road, to City/County standards; 4 short, private driveways required.
  • Access through dune system can be provided by 1 raised walkway.
  • 1 point of connection with the main road.
  • 1 main trench to extend electrical, telephone, water and sewer lines to all residences.
  • No limitations for septic systems.
  • Lot Layout, Buildable Area, Sensitive Resources
  • Smaller lot sizes, each under 1 acre.
  • Minimal grading required for all building pads.
  • Buildable lot area approximately equal: All lots approximately 100% level.
  • Adequate buffer space/open space is provided from lateral access.
  • Dune vegetation is protected from development.

Return to Section 6 Table of Contents

Return to Part 1 of Section 6: Parcel Bisected by a Lagoon

Go to Part 3 of Section 6: Parcel on Ridge Top with Steep Slope

Return to California Coastal Commission Publications List

Return to California Coastal Commission Home Page